85 agentic tools audited for security incidents · Talk to the lab →
MotionticBook a call
Compare

AI agents vs agentic AI: a system, and the category it belongs to

An AI agent is a specific system in which a model directs its own steps and tool calls toward a goal, while agentic AI is the broader category of AI systems that act with some autonomy, covering both fixed workflows that use models and fully model-directed agents.

Checked

The two terms are often used as synonyms, and in casual use the overlap is large. The useful distinction is scope. An AI agent is a thing that can be built, tested and deployed. Agentic AI is the family of approaches it belongs to, which also includes workflows where code, not the model, fixes the path.

For a buyer, the distinction matters because a product sold as agentic AI may be a fixed workflow with model calls inside it. That can be the right design. It is still worth knowing which one is being bought.

How the labs define an AI agent

  • Anthropic

    Groups all these designs as agentic systems, then separates workflows, where code fixes the path, from agents, where the model decides its own steps and tool use.

  • OpenAI

    Describes an agent as a model that controls workflow execution and picks tools within guardrails, built from three parts: model, tools and instructions. A chatbot or single-turn classifier does not count.

  • Google

    Describes an agent as a model plus tools plus an orchestration layer that runs a reason, act and observe cycle.

What agentic AI covers

Agentic AI is a spectrum of autonomy. At one end, a workflow calls a model at fixed points, for example to classify a ticket and then route it by rule. In the middle, a workflow gives a model a bounded choice, such as which of three tools to call. At the far end, an agent receives a goal and works out the steps itself.

All of these are agentic AI. Only the far end is an AI agent in the sense the labs use.

Questions that separate the two in a pitch

  • Who decides the next step?

    If code decides, it is a workflow. If the model decides, it is an agent.

  • Which tools can it call?

    An agent's value comes from the systems it can read and change. A short or empty tool list means a narrow system.

  • What needs approval?

    A clear answer on which actions wait for a person shows the system has been designed for production.

  • How is it evaluated?

    An agent should be scored on task outcomes from real cases, not on a demo.

Where each fits in a product

In Motiontic's thesis on the four levels of AI in a product, AI-native flows (L3) are often agentic workflows: onboarding that configures itself, with the path mostly fixed. An agentic product (L4), where the user states an outcome and supervises, is usually built around one or more agents. Motiontic's engineers pick the design per flow, and keep fixed code wherever the path is known.

An AI agent compared with agentic AI

An AI agent compared with agentic AI
AI agentAgentic AI
What the term namesOne system that can be built and deployedA category of designs and an approach
ScopeModel-directed steps and tool useEverything from model-assisted workflows to agents
Who decides the next stepThe modelCode, the model, or a mix
ExampleAn agent that resolves a support ticket end to endA pipeline that classifies tickets with a model and routes them by rule
Question for a vendorWhich tools, which limits, which evals?Is this a workflow or an agent, and why?

Common questions

Are AI agents and agentic AI the same thing?

Not quite. An AI agent is a specific system where the model directs its own steps and tool calls. Agentic AI is the wider category of AI that acts with some autonomy, and it also includes workflows where code fixes the path.

Is a workflow with LLM calls an AI agent?

No. Anthropic separates workflows, where predefined code paths orchestrate model calls and tools, from agents, where the model decides its own process. A workflow with model calls is agentic AI, but not an agent.

Is a chatbot an AI agent?

Usually not. OpenAI's guide to building agents states that chatbots and single-turn classifiers are not agents, because the model does not control the execution of a task or choose tools to act.

What are the parts of an AI agent?

OpenAI's guide names three: a model, tools for reading data and taking actions, and instructions. In production an agent also needs a harness that runs the loop, plus evals, traces and approval rules.

Should a product use an agent or a simpler agentic workflow?

Anthropic, OpenAI and Google all advise starting with the simplest design that works. Use a workflow where the steps are predictable, and an agent where they cannot be known in advance.

Running agents that have to hold up?

Describe the agent, the systems it touches and what it must never get wrong. The first call is with a lab engineer, who will say plainly whether it is ready for production, and whether Motiontic is the right team.